Credit Card Finder Comparison Service Australia
Compare

Personal Loans vs. Credit Cards In Debt Consolidation


Posted September 7th, 2009 and last modified December 2nd, 2009

Debt consolidation credit cards or personal loans? This is the question facing thousands of people riddled with debt every single day.


It’s not an easy decision to make because of the sheer magnitude of trying to pay off debt. That’s why we have written this article to help you decide what is right for you.


The difference between debt consolidation credit cards and personal loans:

When you take out a debt consolidation card, also called making a balance transfer to a new card you roll all your existing credit card debt into the new card. This balance card offers you better interest rates on purchases plus an introductory period of 0% credit for a specific term, usually six months.


The downfalls of using balance transfers is that when the honeymoon period is over, the interest rate will revert back to much higher rates, often more than traditional credit cards and this is the dangers of dealing with such a card. Unless you pay off your debt in full before the introductory period is over you will end up with more debt instead. Not a good position to be in.


On the other hand, personal loans allow you to borrow money within a set time period, usually between three and five years. During that time you pay back your loan in monthly instalments which are set. This gives you the advantage of knowing how much money you need to save every month.


Personal loans are often cheaper than debt consolidation credit cards because they allow you to repay a debt much sooner of done correctly. On an earlier post we have done a comparison between the two to show you how much money can be saved between the options while paying off your debt all the same.


The result has been rather interesting to say the least. To recap, let’s look at the following example of debt consolidation credit cards vs. personal loans.


If you need to repay a larger debt, such as a home renovation, a car, a boat or a holiday overseas you are better served with a personal loan.


-
In Australia, your best bet for a person loan would be Citibank, because it offers the most flexible and cheapest personal loan to suit the majority consumers.


A Citibank Personal Loan features:

  • A highly competitive interest rate of 13.24%.
  • Loan flexibility from $4000-$75,000.
  • No hassle of a secured loan – enjoy the freedom of unsecured credit.
  • Withdraw any repayment you’ve made over $500.
  • A one-off fee of $150 on application, and ongoing $7 monthly fee.
  • Lump sum repayments available.
  • 1-5 year loan term option.


Comparison of Credit Cards vs Personal Loans:


Look at the following example and see the massive difference in savings between the two:

  • The cost of a 4 Year Citibank Personal Loan Repayment at 13.24%p.a: ((538.94 times 48) plus 150) plus (7 times 48) = $26,355.12
  • The cost of a 4 Year Citibank Platinum Card Purchase Repayment at 19.85% p.a: (607.01 times 48) plus (250 times 5) = $30,386.48


Both of these calculations take into account all ongoing fees. Plus we chose a credit card with a high credit limit to allow for the purchase amount chosen.


It is also apparent that over the span of four years one would require a massive amount of discipline not to use a credit card (other than repaying your debt balance,) it’s near impossible.


The Citibank Personal Loan interest rate is Fixed. Credit card interest rates are subject to change at practically any time the bank wishes, making them risky for long term loans.




So in the debate of debt consolidation credit cards vs. personal loans it all depends on the size of your existing debt, your spending habits and the terms offered.


Related posts:

  1. GE Money Personal Loans including Debt Consolidation – Details & Application
  2. Credit Card Debt Consolidation Loans
  3. Trimming excess debt with credit balance transfers and personal loans
  4. ANZ Debt Consolidation Using A Balance Transfer Or Personal Loan
  5. Debt Consolidation Advice – Information and Services
  6. Credit Card Debt Consolidation
  7. New Year Debt Consolidation Advice



Show Comment Form

Add a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment.
There is no need to resubmit your comment.


Bankwest Balance Transfer Credit Card

Editor's Choice: Our Top Credit Cards


Credit Card Card Details Interest Rate (p.a.) Cash Advance Rate (p.a.) Balance Transfer Rate (p.a.)

Annual fee

Interest free days (up to)

St George  
Vertigo MasterCard Application
St George Vertigo
Editor's Choice:
Low Interest
Low 2.99% for 6 months (reverts to 11.99%) p.a. interest rate and balance transfer rate, from one of Australia's most respected banks.
2.99% for 6 months (reverts to 11.99%) 20.74% 2.99% for 6 months $55 55
Coles Group Source MasterCard
Coles Group Source MasterCard
The Coles Group Source MasterCard has no annual fee, a 0% p.a. balance transfer offer for 6 months, with a rewards program including savings on fuel and FlyBuys Points19.74%21.99%0% for 6 months$062 Apply Now For The Coles Group Source MasterCard
Read More About The Coles Group Source MasterCard
BankWest More Platinum MasterCard
Bankwest Zero Platinum MasterCard
Editor's Choice:
No Annual Fee
Excellent introductory offer with a $0 annual fee for the life of the credit card and a 1.99% p.a. for 9 months on balance transfers
16.99% 16.99% 1.99% for 9 months $0 55

Card Types

Card Tips

The Basics


Credit Card Guide
Learn about different credit card concepts.

Popular Articles


Best Balance Transfers
The most competitive 0% p.a. and 'for life' offers of 2010.

Guide to Credit Ratings
Information about your credit file. Find out what you can apply for with good and bad credit.

Rewards Comparison
Australian reward program details including point capping & expiry.

Foreign Fees & Charges
International transaction charges from credit card companies.

Calculators

Interest Repayment Calculator
Enter your balance(s) to calculate the interest to pay on your cards.

Balance Transfer Calculator
Input a balance transfer offer to calculate your potential savings.
Credit Card News the latest rates & headlines

Free e-Book

NEW: The Ultimate Guide to Balance Transfers
The Australian Guide to Balance Transfers written by Credit Card Finder
Download our FREE e-book normally valued at $24.95. Find out how you can save hundreds to thousands of dollars on your credit cards via balance transfers.

Enter your email below to receive our Free e-book.



   

Get Free Updates





 

As seen on:

Today Tonight

Today Show

ABC Television





Sky News

Herald Sun

Channel 10

Australian Web Industry Association

Anthill Magazine



Credit Card Management Tips Credit Card Guides Personal Finance Tips and Advice
Partnered Sites Secondary Credit Card Providers About CreditCardFinder.com.au

Savings Accounts Comparison
Fido Credit Card Information Guide to choosing
a card, and general day-to-day tips on living
with and managing your card
Understanding Credit Understand your options
and what you will pay in interest and charges
Stay Smart Online advice on how
to secure your computer and your
transactions online
Debt Management Guide
Request a copy of your credit file

Bank of Queensland Credit Cards Bank of Queensland

Bendigo Bank Credit Cards Bendigo Bank

Credit Union Australia Credit Cards CUA

IMB Credit Cards IMB

Jetstar Credit Cards Jetstar

Macquarie Bank Credit CardsMacquarie Bank

Member's Equity Credit Cards Members Equity

Virgin Credit Card Virgin Credit Cards

Wizard Credit Cards Wizard

MasterCard Credit Cards MasterCard Credit

Visa Credit Cards Visa Credit Cards

Contact Us
About Us
Blog
RSS
Privacy Policy
Sitemap

100% GreenPower Carbon Neutral Website